NBC Nightly News  (1/23, story 8, 0:30, Guthrie) reported, "A 
Stanford Medical Center study found women report feeling more pain than 
men do on a variety of common ailments including back and neck injuries,
 digestive problems and sinus infections. The author said part of the 
reason women reported much higher levels of pain could be because men 
simply don't want to admit how much pain they experience."
       
"New research from Stanford University suggests that even when men and 
women have the same condition -- whether it's a back problem, arthritis 
or a sinus infection -- women appear to suffer more from the pain," the New York Times
  (1/24, Parker-Pope) "Well" blog adds.  "The study, published Monday in
 The Journal of Pain, analyzes data from the electronic medical records 
of 11,000 patients whose pain scores were recorded as a
routine part of their care."  According to the study, "for 21 of 22 
ailments with sample sizes large enough to make a meaningful comparison,
 the researchers found that women reported higher levels of pain than 
men."
       
On its front page, the San Francisco Chronicle
  (1/24, A1, Allday) reports, "The study being released today found that
 when asked to rate their pain on a scale of 0 to 10 -- with 0 being no 
pain at all, and 10 being the worst pain imaginable -- women on average 
scored their pain 20 percent more intense than men."  What more, "the 
results held up across a wide variety of diseases and injuries, 
including back and neck pain,
digestive disorders, sinus infections, and even ankle strains and 
sprains."  But "the fact that women report more pain overall doesn't 
necessarily mean they have more or less tolerance to pain than men," 
study lead author Dr. Atul Butte said.
       
"Authors cautioned that this study cannot determine whether pain is 
actually experienced more intensely by women or whether women simply 
communicate better with their health care providers about pain," ABC News
 (1/24, James, Chuang) points out.  "But many other medical experts are 
skeptical about the Stanford study" since "the authors didn't account 
for the possibility that if many women had additional diseases that 
caused pain,
it could actually be the other diseases, and not their gender, which is 
responsible for the women having more pain than men."  Dr. Lloyd 
Saberski, medical director of the Advanced Diagnostic Pain Treatment 
Centers at Yale University, said, "It's a flawed study."
       
CBS News
 (1/24, DyBuncio) reports that "since the data were self-reported, the 
explanation may be that women more readily report pain than men do."  
Another explanation for the difference may be that "since nurses often 
take these records, men may have been more reluctant to admit their pain
 to female nurses. Or the difference may be hormonal."  Also covering 
the story are the Wall Street Journal  (1/24, Shea) "Ideas Market" blog, San Jose Mercury News (1/24, Shen), and the New York Daily News  (1/24, Murray).
No comments:
Post a Comment